Angel Girl by Laurie Friedman, illustrations by Ofra
Amit
Book Review by Sandy
Hall
“Herman
lives in a labor camp. It is 1942, and the Nazis have made him a prisoner. He
is forced to work long hours. His only food is soup made of water. Soon he
loses the will to go on.
“Then
she appears. A young girl on the other side of the barbed-wire fence – an angel
girl, bearing food and hope in the most hopeless of times. She seems like a
miracle.
“For
Herman, the miracles have just begun…..
“Based
on a true tale of survival, Angel Girl
is a story of love, hope, and the strength of the human spirit.” (quoted from
the dust jacket)
This
beautiful story is told by Laurie Friedman and illustrated by Ofra Amit.
Published in 2008, the book tells the story of a young Polish Jewish boy of
eleven caught up in the events of World War II. His mother tells him to say he
is sixteen when they are taken to a concentration camp. He lives and works in
the camp with the men but gradually loses hope. A young girl outside the camp
begins to appear each day and throws him an apple. When the camp is liberated,
he never sees her again…..that is, until one day…….
You
may want to watch this youtube video about this boy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ULcvUxd_Ngo.
Although there has been much written and said about this story being untrue since
the book was published, including Herman who later admitted it was not true, still
it is a beautiful story. The book was removed from publication, which is
probably why I found an ex-library copy at a thrift store. If it was reprinted
without claiming to be a true story, it would perhaps then be an enjoyable read
as fiction.
Laurie
Friedman wanted to be an author since she was in third grade. She was born in
1964 and grew up in Arkansas. She attended Tulane University where she studied
literature, and also studied at Sorbonne University in Paris, France. She spent
many years writing for the advertising industry and as a free-lance writer for
newspapers and magazines. Friedman has written many books for children
including the Mallory McDonald chapter books and The Mostly Miserable Life of April Sinclair. I have not read or
seen those but they seem to be typical modern realistic fiction. She writes, “It
makes me feel better when I read about a character going through something
similar to what I’m going through, and seeing how that character handles the
situation.” Laurie also have written some rhyming children’s picture books.
Ofra
Amit “has illustrated several children’s picture books in Israel…..Angel Girl is her first children’s
picture book in the United States. She hopes the illustrations will help bring
this inspiring story into readers’ hearts. Ms. Amit lives in Sede Warburg,
Israel.” (from the dust jacket) She is one of Israel’s premiere illustrators
and has won many awards. Her work is very modern and abstract which I don’t
normally enjoy. Her drawings of people’s
faces are always with long noses and wide-set eyes. In the case of this book’s
illustrations, these sad faces work perfectly with the text. She conveys the
fear, struggles, and hopelessness of the concentration camp without being too
vivid.
Over
the years, many moms of elementary children have asked for books about the
Holocaust that would be appropriate for their families. Often it’s difficult to
find books that tell the story without being too harsh for younger, more sensitive
children. I think there are two sides to this issue of exposure to such horrors.
Those who died and those who survived should never be forgotten. The depravity
of man can sink to a very low point which usually doesn’t help a child to know.
And yet, these stories of survival, courage, and the strength of humankind in
the worst of difficulties should be told. And stories like this the one in this
book show the providence of God even in the hardest of circumstances. This book
should definitely be pre-read by a parent before sharing it with your children.
Then be ready to discuss the mature content in light of historic events. I
think if my own children were young, I would wait until age 10 and older, even
though this is a picture book. And we would read it along with our studies of
world history and those tragic events.
Many
years ago, I made a journey to Israel to study at the Jerusalem Institute of
Holy Land Studies. Our group took a day to visit the Yad Vashem, a museum in
honor of those Jews killed in the Holocaust as well as a memorial of the
Gentiles who came to the aid of many Jews. Being there was a humbling
experience, even for me as a young adult. How pampered we are with our “first-world
problems.” I admired the courage of Gentiles who helped to hide Jews at the risk
of their own lives. At the Yad Vashem, I saw children visiting with their
families despite the utter terror of the large photos and videos. The Jews want
their families to remember, to know. Perhaps we are a little too removed here
in America, both geographically and historically, from this kind of persecution.
I don’t know….it will be up to you as parents to know and to tell in your own
time what happened there so long ago.
Other
books have been written for children and young people on the Holocaust and
World War II that show the awful, fearful side, but also tell of courage,
survival, the struggles to rebuild, the sacrifices made for others. These
books, I believe, help to balance the dark side of this historic event with
light. I don’t think it hurts to think through how I would act in the same
situations, and to help our children ponder that as well. Would I follow the
example of those who faced the evil and countered it with good?
Another
picture book along this theme that I have included in my library is Elisabeth by Claire A. Nivola. This book
tells the story of a young Jewish girl who loved her doll very much but had to
made the difficult decision to leave her behind when her family is forced to
flee Germany during World War II. Eventually, that doll finds its way back to
her. I highly recommend this title; it is less graphic about the Holocaust than
Angel Girl and still helps you see the providence of God
in an amazing way.
Another
picture book that I recommend is Mercedes
and the Chocolate Pilot by Margot Theis Raven, although it takes place just
after World War II. When Stalin blocked all ground routes coming in and out of
Berlin, Americans and Britains helped to fly in supplies. This is the true
story of a seven-year-old girl and one of the pilots who brought hope to the
children.
The Yellow Star: The
Legend of King Christian X of Denmark, written by Carmen Agra Deedy, and
illustrated by Henri Sorensen, retells the story in picture book form of King
Christian and the Danish resistance to the Nazis in World War II. This story is
a legend, and there is no proof
this story is true, but it “has been passed down through the years as fact.
It's a story about the kind of leader you always want to serve, who is
thoughtful, intelligent, and loves his people. This is a great short story to
use in the study of WWII.” (Amazon review)
Irena Sendler and the Children of the
Warsaw Ghetto by Susan Goldman
Rubin and illustrated by Bill Farnsworth. “Irena Sendler, a Polish social worker, helped nearly four
hundred Jewish children out of the Warsaw Ghetto and into hiding during World
War II.” (amazon review)
One Thousand Tracings: Healing the Wounds
of World War II. When
author/illustrator Lita Judge found hundreds of tracings of feet in her
grandmother’s attic, she was intrigued and moved to share the story behind them.
Judge bases this quiet, moving story of kindness and healing on her own
family's history. After World War II, her grandparents organized a relief
effort from their Midwest farm and sent care packages to more than 3,000
desperate people in Europe. In each spread, a young girl describes how she
helps Mama with the packages. The stirring art in Judge's first picture book
includes not only beautiful, full-page watercolor paintings of a family making
a difference but also dramatic collages of black-and-white photos, newspaper
cuttings, letters that Judge found in her grandparents' attic, and the foot
tracings sent by Europeans desperate for shoes. There is no talk of the enemy.
Judge focuses on the dramatic, realistic details of those in need ("We
have only one pair of boots and must take turns") and the strength of
those who fought "a battle to keep families alive" after the military
battles were over. (amazon review)
The next step up from a picture book that I would recommend
is the short chapter book The Little
Riders by Margaretha Shemin, illustrated by Peter Spier. "Take care of the little riders,"
says Johanna's father to the eleven-year-old when he leaves her with his
parents for an extended vacation in their Dutch village. And Johanna does. She
loves the twelve metal figures on horseback who ride forth each hour from the
clock on the ancient church tower. She would do anything to protect them,
anything. And on night she risks her life to prove it. Set during the Second World War when the German army occupied
Holland, The Little Riders is
an exciting, moving adventure story, just right for reading aloud. (Amazon
review)
If you do find Angel
Girl and read it, please let me know your thoughts.
(all rights reserved. Sandy Hall 4/7/2018. Please ask
permission to publish this elsewhere. Thank you.)
